Supermarket Pizza Showdown: The Top 8 Pies for a Perfect Night In
Pizza remains a go-to choice for a quick and satisfying meal, whether you are hosting friends or simply taking a break from cooking. Supermarket pizzas have evolved significantly, offering premium toppings like truffle oil, king prawns, and fiery 'nduja on hand-stretched sourdough bases that rival restaurant quality. With each person estimated to consume over 5,000 slices in a lifetime, finding the best options is essential. To simplify your decision, we conducted a blind taste test of a wide range of supermarket pizzas, focusing on light, well-risen dough, deeply flavoured tomato sauces, crisp finishes, and that all-important cheese pull.
The Best Supermarket Pizzas for 2026
Our rigorous testing, involving a panel of hungry friends, evaluated margherita pizzas from various supermarkets to ensure fairness. Here are the standout winners across different categories.
1. Morrisons The Best Mozzarella, Cherry Tomato and Basil Pesto Pizza
Best Supermarket Pizza Overall
This pizza impressed with its herby and peppery flavours, offering a premium taste at excellent value. The sourdough and Italian rye base is pillowy soft with good thickness, complemented by a flavoursome tomato sauce. Fresh cherry tomatoes, pesto, and oozy mozzarella add visual and taste appeal, though some testers desired more basil sauce. Priced at £4, it is a solid choice for any occasion.
2. Tesco Finest Margherita Wood Fired Pizza
Best Thick Supermarket Pizza
Featuring soft dough, delicious fresh basil, and mozzarella balls, this pizza from Tesco's finest range offers a luxury feel. The tomato sauce is high-quality, and the cheese crisps up nicely when baked. However, the base may be too bready for some, lacking crispiness. At £5, it is ideal for those who prefer thicker crusts.
3. Co-op Wood-Fired Margherita
Best Supermarket Pizza for Flavour
A crowd-pleaser from Co-op's irresistible range, this pizza boasts a pillowy soft centre and a crisped-up crust for a satisfying crunch. Tangy, juicy cherry tomatoes burst with flavour, enhanced by a pesto drizzle, though testers wished for more pesto. Priced at £6, it delivers artisanal appeal and rich taste.
4. M&S Classic Margherita Pizza
Best Crisp Supermarket Pizza
This classic margherita features satisfyingly stringy cheese and a moreish tomato sauce spread right to the crust. The crust crisps up well, while the base stays soft, though the tomato sauce lacks depth and richness. At £4, it is the priciest option tested but remains enjoyable for crispness lovers.
5. Sainsbury's Stonebaked Margherita Pizza
Best Supermarket Pizza for Cheese Toppings
Generous lashings of mozzarella and cheddar melt beautifully, creating a crisp, golden top with a soft, fluffy dough beneath. However, the tomato sauce is overly sweet and lacks savoury depth. Priced at £4, it excels in cheese texture but falls short on sauce flavour.
6. Doughboys Classic Margherita Pizza
Best Supermarket Pizza Dough
Founded by Reading-based twins, this pizza offers a high-quality, slow-proved, hand-stretched base with excellent flavour and texture. The cheese is rich and crisp, though the tomato sauce could be more generous. At £4, it is one of the pricier options but stands out for premium dough.
7. White Rabbit Gluten Free Sourdough Vegan Margherita Pizza
Best Vegan Supermarket Pizza
Catering to vegan and gluten-free diets, this pizza uses 'mozzarisella' cheese alternative, which may taste artificial to non-vegans. The sourdough base is chewy and flavourful, with rich sun-dried tomatoes and a strong pesto layer. Priced at £3, it is a good option for those avoiding dairy and gluten.
8. Picard Superior Margherita Pizza
Best Neapolitan-Style Supermarket Pizza
Loaded with grated and thick balls of mozzarella, this pizza has a soft, floppy Neapolitan-style crust. The cheese is indulgent, but the base lacks flavour and the tomato sauce is skimpy. At £4, it offers cheesy richness but misses balance.
How We Tested the Best Supermarket Pizzas
Our testing criteria included dough flavour and texture, tomato sauce richness, and cheese quality. We blind-tasted margherita pizzas to ensure fairness, noting crust crunch, sauce depth, and topping generosity. This approach guarantees reliable recommendations for your next supermarket shop.
