A woman's claim to have found the 'perfect' method for making a cup of tea has ignited a fiery debate and left many Britons utterly baffled. The controversy erupted on social media after she shared her unconventional technique for brewing a mammoth mug of Yorkshire Tea.
The Brew That Caused The Uproar
On the Reddit forum 'Rate My Tea', the user posted a picture of her substantial brew with the caption: "Yorkshire Tea - 3 bags, 20oz cup." The sheer volume of the mug, holding over half a litre, was one thing, but it was the use of three teabags to achieve a surprisingly weak-looking colour that sent the British internet into a spin.
Fellow tea enthusiasts were quick to express their confusion and annoyance. One commenter summed up the mood, stating: "Why you need three bags to achieve that colour is a mystery, and it's annoyed me." The debate quickly centred on the mathematics and science of a proper brew, with many insisting one bag was sufficient for a standard mug.
A Clash of Brewing Philosophies
The original poster defended her method, questioning how many bags others would use for such a large volume. This prompted a detailed exchange on the finer points of tea-making. A respondent argued: "One teabag is good enough for around 200-300ml unless you like weak tea," suggesting two at most for her cup.
The conversation then took a sharper turn, with another user advising: "once you need more than one bag get a f****** tea pot." The poster later revealed she preferred a "very malty brew with sweetener and milk," which opened a secondary debate on whether to squeeze the teabag against the mug.
Technical brewing times were also debated. One user theorised that three bags brewed for one minute equated to one bag for three minutes, while another countered that longer brewing releases more tannins, creating a different flavour profile entirely.
Praise Amidst The Controversy
Despite the fury, the colossal cuppa did find its admirers. Some users rated it a "10/10 brew," with one declaring it "perfect, no notes." When questioned on her triple-bag strategy, the original poster cheekily retorted: "Because it's not WW2 and we don't need to ration tea, lol."
The incident, which took place on 03 January 2026, proves that in Britain, the method behind making a simple cup of tea is never just about hydration—it's a deeply held matter of national pride and personal principle. Whether you're a one-bag traditionalist or a multi-bag maverick, one thing is clear: everyone has an opinion on the perfect brew.
