A taste test of supermarket brown sauces has crowned Aldi's 99p offering as the winner, beating the iconic HP brand. The test, conducted by a self-proclaimed brown sauce enthusiast, compared sauces from Aldi, Asda, M&S, Sainsbury's, Lidl, and Daddies.
HP sauce, which costs around £3.90 for 600g, has been a staple for over 100 years. However, the Aldi sauce impressed with its consistency, depth, and tanginess, closely matching HP's flavour profile. The tester noted they would even choose Aldi's sauce over HP in the future.
Asda's sauce came a close second, offering a remarkably similar taste to HP with the right spices and tanginess. Lidl's sauce was praised for its powerful aroma and spice, though it was milder in flavour. Daddies delivered the expected kick but required a generous amount for full flavour.
Sainsbury's sauce was ranked lowest, described as diluted and lacking the desired kick. M&S sauce was criticised for being too sweet, with a flavour reminiscent of mango chutney. The test highlights that budget-friendly options can rival premium brands in taste.
