For many, the search for the perfect pair of jeans is a frustrating and often fruitless endeavour. Journalist Jessica Brunt, writing on January 17, 2026, decided to put one of the most talked-about denim styles to the test: the High Waisted Carrot Leg Ankle Grazer Jeans from Marks & Spencer.
The Quest for the Perfect Jean
Despite being a self-confessed shopping enthusiast, Brunt admits that jean shopping is her sartorial nemesis. The common issues of awkward lengths and unflattering fits led her to M&S with low expectations, aiming to see if the £40 carrot jeans could possibly live up to their substantial online hype.
The jeans are available in a wide range of UK sizes from 6 to 24 and come in multiple colours, including three blue shades, black, and a spring-like ecru. A key selling point is the inclusive leg length options, which run from extra short to long, though some colours are already selling out online.
Putting the Carrot Fit to the Test
Designed with a flattering high waist and a tapered ankle-grazer leg, the carrot style is touted as ideal for everyday wear. Brunt, who is 5'7" and prefers a longer leg, tried the long length in the ecru colour. With slimmer legs and curvier hips, she often struggles to find denim that accommodates both.
Upon trying them on, she was pleasantly surprised by the fit. The jeans offered a relaxed drape on the legs while cinching neatly at the waist, creating a silhouette she found very flattering. She experimented with both tucked-in and loose tops, finding both styles worked well.
She went true to size and noted the waistband has limited stretch, which might not suit those who prefer more flexibility. However, as the jeans aren't skin-tight, they didn't feel overly restrictive. Her one criticism of the ecru colour was that the material was slightly sheer at the top, revealing pocket lining.
Verdict: A Modern Wardrobe Staple?
Overall, Brunt was really impressed with the M&S carrot jeans. She found them to be a great alternative to barrel-leg jeans, which she feels don't always flatter her shape. She advises potential buyers to try them with different shoes due to the ankle-grazer length and, crucially, to sit down in them to test real-world comfort.
Her positive experience is echoed in hundreds of five-star reviews online. One shopper hailed them as the 'perfect fit', while another revealed a fashion consultant had recommended the style as it 'will suit most figures'. A third reviewer praised their comfort and versatility.
While there are cheaper jeans on the high street, Brunt concludes that the £40 price point is justified for a design that skims the tummy and offers a modern, gently relaxed leg—a potential new staple for the discerning shopper.
