YouTuber Convicted of Murder After Fake Gaming Livestream Alibi Unravels
A YouTuber who attempted to establish a false alibi by broadcasting a pre-recorded video-gaming session online has been found guilty of murdering his pregnant partner. Stephen McCullagh, 36, was convicted by a jury at Belfast Crown Court for the violent killing of Natalie McNally, 32, who was 15 weeks pregnant at the time of her death in December 2022.
False Alibi Exposed by Cybercrime Investigation
The trial revealed that McCullagh, known online as votesaxon07, had livestreamed himself playing video games on the evening of McNally's murder, claiming to be drinking alcohol and engaging with viewers. However, the Police Service of Northern Ireland's cybercrime unit conducted a thorough examination of his devices, uncovering extensive evidence that the footage was actually pre-recorded on 14 December and saved as a video file.
McCullagh had advertised the stream on his social media as a "surprise" event titled The Violent Night Christmas Live Gaming Stream. In the footage, he wore a Santa hat and discussed technical issues, informing viewers he would not respond to live chat or use his phone. This elaborate setup was intended to create the impression he was at home during the time of the crime.
Details of the Crime and Trial Proceedings
Natalie McNally was attacked and killed at her home in Lurgan, County Armagh, between 8.50pm and 9.30pm on 18 December 2022. The prosecution argued that McCullagh travelled to Lurgan, murdered McNally, and then returned to his house in Lisburn via taxi. McNally suffered stab wounds and blows to her head during the violent assault.
After being rearrested in January, McCullagh admitted in a pre-prepared statement to police that he had pre-recorded the livestream footage. He claimed he had been consuming alcohol and asleep for most of the evening when McNally was killed. However, the jury of six men and six women deliberated for just two hours before reaching a guilty verdict.
Emotional Courtroom Scene and Family Statements
As the verdict was read out, McCullagh stood without expression in the dock, while McNally's family and friends filled the public gallery and cheered in relief. Outside the court, McNally's family expressed gratitude for the support from friends, family, and the wider public, stating it helped them through this difficult time.
Niall McNally, Natalie's brother, said, "As Natalie receives justice today, our hearts go out to all the victims of violence against women and girls. Our hope is that all the victims and families get their day in court, and the justice they deserve." Another brother, Declan, described Natalie as "an inspirational person" and added, "Having you in our lives was the greatest joy we'll ever have. You would have been an amazing mother to baby Dean. We will love you forever and we hope you can now rest easy." He also praised their parents for their strength in holding the family together.
Sentencing and Future Proceedings
The trial judge, Mr Justice Kinney, informed McCullagh that murder carries a mandatory life sentence. A tariff hearing to determine the minimum time he must spend in jail before being considered for release is scheduled for May. The case highlights the increasing role of digital evidence in criminal investigations, particularly in debunking fabricated alibis through cybercrime expertise.
