An aspiring rapper is facing trial at Chelmsford Crown Court after a 68-year-old grandmother was fatally mauled by two XL bully dogs in what prosecutors have described as a 'tragedy waiting to happen'.
Fatal Attack in Jaywick, Essex
Esther Martin was left in charge of ten dogs at the home of Ashley Warren in Jaywick, Essex, on 3 February 2024, while he travelled to London to film a music video. The attack occurred just two days after it became a criminal offence to own an XL bully in England and Wales without an exemption certificate. Warren had not obtained such certificates for any of his dogs, placing him in breach of the new law.
Prosecution's Case: A Preventable Incident
The prosecution argued that Ms Martin, who had mobility issues and minimal dog training experience, was not a suitable person to manage the powerful XL bully breeds. They emphasised that the situation was inherently dangerous, given her limitations and the dogs' strength, labelling it a clear case of negligence that led to her death.
Defence Claims and Contradictions
Ashley Warren denies the charges, asserting that he reasonably believed Ms Martin was a 'fit and proper person' to care for the dogs. However, this claim is contradicted by previous statements he made to police, where he reportedly said that poodles are more aggressive than XL bullies, raising questions about his understanding of the risks involved.
Legal and Safety Implications
The trial highlights the ongoing concerns surrounding XL bully ownership and enforcement of regulations. With the attack happening so soon after the new law took effect, it underscores the critical need for compliance and proper supervision to prevent such tragedies in the future.
The case continues at Chelmsford Crown Court, with further evidence expected to be presented in the coming days.
