For those who find traditional festive fare a little too saccharine, Film 4 offers an alternative tonight with a Christmas film billed as being 'for people who hate Christmas movies.'
A Festive Premiere With a Twist
The channel is set to broadcast 'Happiest Season' on Monday 22 December at 9pm. This holiday romantic comedy features a star-studded cast including Kristen Stewart, Mackenzie Davis, and Dan Levy. The plot centres on Abby (Stewart), who plans to propose to her girlfriend Harper (Davis) during her family's Christmas celebrations.
The festive spirit quickly sours when Abby discovers Harper has not come out to her conservative parents. Harper then asks Abby to pretend to be her straight, orphaned roommate for the duration of the visit. This deception sets the stage for a holiday filled with awkward encounters, family drama, and a poignant struggle for authenticity.
Mixed Reviews From Critics and Audiences
Since its initial release in late November 2020, followed by premieres in the U.S., UK, and Canada, the film has garnered a decidedly mixed reception. While some have praised its modern take on the genre, others have been far less charitable.
On the review aggregation site Rotten Tomatoes, fans have celebrated the film's fresh perspective. One viewer called it "a refreshing holiday movie: funny and heartwarming," while another declared it an "instant classic" they would revisit every year. Supporters highlighted its humour, heartwarming moments, and its thematic exploration of the pressure to maintain a perfect facade.
However, the critical consensus is far from unanimous. Detractors have been scathing in their assessments. One damning review labelled the film "appallingly bad" and "completely unoriginal and full of cliche," comparing its humour to outdated slapstick. Another critic took issue with the central relationship's dynamics, arguing the film sent a poor message about tolerating manipulation.
Why the Film Divides Opinion
The polarising nature of 'Happiest Season' seems to stem from its attempt to blend classic holiday movie tropes with a contemporary LGBTQ+ narrative. For some, this fusion represents a long-overdue and welcome evolution of the festive film. For others, the execution of its familiar plot beats feels tired and unconvincing.
This split makes it a particularly intriguing broadcast choice. Rather than offering comfortable, predictable viewing, Film 4 is presenting a film that actively sparks debate about what a modern Christmas story can and should be.
Whether you find it a groundbreaking festive treat or a seasonal misfire, 'Happiest Season' promises to be one of the more talked-about television movie events this Christmas. Viewers can make up their own minds when it airs tonight on Film 4.
