Channel Nine's cherished Christmas Eve broadcast, Carols by Candlelight, has ignited a storm of controversy and mixed reviews, primarily centred on a divisive comedic performance and allegations of network rivalry influencing the lineup.
Comedian's Unconventional Set Divides Audience
The annual festive special, screened on Wednesday night, saw Melbourne-based comedian Sammy J, 42, take to the stage with a series of humorous songs. His performance included a quirky ode to an unusual Christmas dinner of gingerbread, tuna, and broccoli pudding, which he joked his aunty makes yearly despite no one eating it.
Sammy J continued with his own distinctive takes on classic carols, injecting rock references and aiming for light-hearted fun. However, the veteran performer's gags largely failed to land with a significant portion of the home audience.
Social Media Erupts with Criticism and Praise
Viewers quickly turned to social media platform X to voice their displeasure. One unimpressed viewer posted, 'You Victorians warned me about Sammy J and I still watched it... Oh boy.' Another speculated, 'Might be the last time Sammy J appears at Carols,' while others noted the absence of his famous puppet sidekick, Randy.
Despite the criticism, a contingent of fans defended the act. Supporters praised Sammy J's energy and audience interaction, with one writing, 'Loved Sammy's segment. He always delivers, and the audience participation was great.'
Behind the Scenes: Allegations of a Network Snub
The controversy surrounding the broadcast extended beyond the stage. Industry insiders claim Channel Nine deliberately excluded winners from The Voice and Australian Idol from this year's carols line-up due to network politics.
According to sources, despite being among the biggest new vocal talents discovered in 2025, Idol winner Marshal Hamburger, 20, and The Voice champion Alyssa Delpopolo, 19, were shut out. The reason cited is that both singing competition franchises now air on rival network Channel Seven.
A former Australian Idol judge lamented the decision, stating that performing at Carols was a traditional rite of passage that helped contestants become recognised artists. The apparent consensus is that Nine did not want to promote a rival network's shows on its flagship Christmas broadcast.
In a twist, Channel Seven has reportedly secured both young singers for its own rival Christmas event, Carols in the Domain, in Sydney's Domain Gardens. Seven executives are said to be 'thrilled' with the coup.
The dual controversies have cast a shadow over the annual tradition, highlighting the fierce competition between broadcasters and the unpredictable nature of live festive entertainment.
