The latest series of the BBC's hit show The Traitors has introduced a dramatic new twist, sending its dedicated fanbase into a frenzy of detective work. Host Claudia Winkleman revealed in the first episode, which aired on New Year's Day, that alongside the usual three Traitors, a fourth 'Secret Traitor' was in play, unknown even to the other deceivers and the audience.
The Hunt for the Hidden Deceiver
Since the twist was announced, viewers have been scrutinising every frame for clues. The intrigue centres on the identity of this lone operator, who wears a distinctive red cloak, unlike the traditional green, and holds the power to dictate a shortlist of Faithful players for murder each night. Now, a compelling fan theory has gained significant traction online, pinpointing one contestant as the prime suspect.
Why Fans Are Pointing at Jack
A key theory circulating among superfans suggests the Secret Traitor is Jack, a personal trainer and competitive chess player. Proponents of this idea argue his strategic, solitary mindset makes him perfectly suited for the role. "He is a chess player who is used to working by himself," one fan noted, highlighting the isolated nature of the secret role.
The most convincing evidence for many revolves around a potential editing choice. Fans observed that during the first round table, where players wrote down names, the show displayed handwriting on most contestants' voting boards—but allegedly not Jack's. "They focused in on everyone’s board at the round table except Jack’s," commented one viewer, "and now I’m convinced he’s the secret traitor and we didn’t see his handwriting for a reason." This has led to speculation that producers hid his writing to prevent a match with the scroll given to the main Traitors.
Social Media Buzz and Consensus
Online reaction has solidified this theory for many. On social media, one user posted a side-by-side comparison, asking "Could Jack be the Secret Traitor??" Another declared emphatically, "Jack is the secret traitor I just knoooowwwwwwww." Others referenced the show's emphasis on his chess background as a clear signal. "They specifically showed us the clip where he says he plays chess every day and competitively, is strategic, and good at reading people," another fan quipped. "This kind of role in the background suits him perfectly."
The three known Traitors selected at the start are Rachel, Stephen, and Hugo, who were visibly shocked to learn a fourth was operating in the shadows. The Secret Traitor twist is reportedly designed to give viewers the authentic experience of being a Faithful, completely in the dark about the deceivers in their midst.
The Traitors continues with a new episode on Wednesday, January 7, at 8pm on BBC One and BBC iPlayer.
