In a dramatic twist on the latest series of ITV's hit show The Masked Singer, the identity of the mysterious Toastie costume has been 'confirmed' by eagle-eyed viewers as none other than soul icon and former EastEnders star Mica Paris. This revelation came after a clever clue in her video package, which featured several well-known personalities from Bolton, sailed completely over the heads of the judging panel but was quickly deciphered by sharp fans at home.
The Clue That Gave It Away
During Toastie's previous performance, her VT included a cryptic reference to Bolton, which the panel interpreted as a location-based hint. However, dedicated viewers immediately connected the dots, recognising it as a nod to Mica Paris's renowned collaboration with singer Michael Bolton. This subtle but telling clue has convinced many that there is 'no way' the celebrity behind the mask isn't Mica, who also enjoyed a stint on the BBC soap EastEnders as Ellie Nixon in 2022.
Toastie's Impressive Vocal Prowess
Undoubtedly one of the most impressive vocalists in the current series, Toastie has quickly become a firm favourite to claim The Masked Singer crown this year. Her powerful performances have left audiences in awe, yet her name remains unmentioned by the judges, adding to the intrigue and speculation surrounding her true identity.
Alternative Theories and Speculation
Prior to this weekend's instalment, the only other celebrity matching Mica's odds was Loose Women panellist and West End star Brenda Edwards. Some viewers speculated that Toastie sounds 'identical to' Brenda, who has carved out a stellar career in shows like Hairspray and Chicago since competing on The X Factor over two decades ago.
Judges on the show also leaned towards Brenda, with Jane Moore confidently stating, "I am totally convinced it's you. I can't work out the red hat but I'm thinking Toastie because you're always warm. I am convinced. I will put money on it right now." Meanwhile, in the first round, Davina McCall guessed it was Big Brother icon Craig Phillips, Jonathan Ross thought it might be Fergie or Jennifer Hudson, Maya Jama was sure it was Emelie Sande, and Mo Gilligan suggested Rebecca Ferguson.
Fan Reactions and Social Media Buzz
Fans at home have been equally divided, with many taking to social media to share their theories. One fan wrote on X, "Calling it now, Toastie is Brenda Edwards," while another said, "I'm going with Brenda Edwards for Toastie. #MaskedSingerUK." A third added, "Toastie - Brenda Edwards. #MaskedSingerUK." However, some viewers were convinced it might be Marcus Collins, known from X Factor, or even fellow ITV Daytime star Alison Hammond, with many claiming to hear a give-away Brummie accent underneath the fake Liverpool accent attempted in the performance.
Brenda Edwards' Response to the Rumours
As speculation mounted, Brenda Edwards addressed the rumours, revealing that her phone had been 'going off' with messages from friends and fans. Coleen Nolan even texted her to ask if she was behind the mask after watching last week's performance. Brenda, however, continued to deflect, saying, "I'm really enjoying the show, it's really exciting and entertaining, isn't it? You've all been asking, stop it." Her non-committal response has only fuelled further debate among viewers.
With the Bolton clue now in the spotlight, the consensus among many fans is firmly leaning towards Mica Paris as the true identity of Toastie. As the competition heats up, all eyes will be on the next performance to see if any further hints emerge to confirm or debunk this popular theory.
