Greggs, the beloved British high street bakery, is famous for its iconic sausage rolls and steak bakes. However, a recent online discussion has turned the spotlight onto the chain's more unsung offerings, with fans passionately debating which menu item deserves far more recognition.
The Reddit Question That Started It All
On January 12, 2026, a user on the social platform Reddit posed a simple but compelling question to fellow Greggs enthusiasts: what is the most underrated item on the menu? The thread quickly ignited, revealing a strong and perhaps unexpected contender for the top spot.
While some users championed lesser-known savoury bakes like the veggie, chicken, and corned beef options, one suggestion garnered significant attention. A user boldly declared that Greggs coffee was the chain's "finest offering," praising it as both high quality and remarkably cheap. They even stated they would choose it over pricier rivals like Starbucks or Costa.
Coffee Praise and Peculiar Gripes
This claim found swift support from other coffee drinkers. One fan described the flat white as "great," while another insisted the Pumpkin Spiced Latte (PSL) was superior to Starbucks' version. However, the conversation also revealed that the coffee experience isn't always consistent.
Some contributors noted that the quality can vary between branches, largely dependent on the age of the coffee machines. "The older machines the coffee is weaker," explained one user, adding that newer models had brewed a stronger cup that upset some regulars. Another had a more unusual complaint, finding the process of waiting for their drink created an "awkward linger" in the shop.
Not everyone was convinced, of course. One disgruntled customer, receiving free monthly coffees through an insurance promotion, concluded it was "the worst coffee I've drank from a chain."
Beyond the Coffee: A Chorus of Forgotten Favourites
The debate naturally expanded beyond hot drinks, with many fans using the platform to pay tribute to other overlooked gems. One nostalgic customer lamented the loss of the Warm Winter Veg soup, which disappeared before the Covid pandemic.
Others sang the praises of current menu items, calling the mac and cheese "good" and hailing the roast chicken mayo baguette as "god tier" compared to other bakery meal deals. The cheese bites also received a strong endorsement, with one fan declaring them superior to McDonald's, offering better value for money.
The discussion proves that while Greggs' classics will always have their place, there's a whole world of flavour on the menu waiting to be rediscovered and celebrated by loyal customers. So, which Greggs item do you think is the most underrated?
