Shoplifter's Aggressive Behaviour Leads to Security Guard's Fatal Heart Attack in Arbroath
A shoplifter whose aggressive and threatening conduct resulted in the death of an Asda security guard has been warned she faces a substantial prison sentence. The tragic incident unfolded at the supermarket in Arbroath, Angus, where Alun Harris-Richards, a 61-year-old former Royal Marine, suffered a fatal heart attack during a confrontation.
Court Hears Details of Fatal Confrontation
Natasha Smith, aged 38, admitted to culpable homicide after her actions caused Mr Harris-Richards to collapse and die at his workplace on June 30, 2024. The High Court in Edinburgh was told that Smith, while attempting to leave the store with stolen alcohol, engaged in a physical struggle with the security guard. During the altercation, she shouted, swore, and falsely accused him of assaulting her.
The charge detailed that Mr Harris-Richards, who had an undiagnosed heart condition, endured such intense physical and emotional stress that he sustained a heart attack, fell to the ground, struck his head, and died. Prosecutors noted that the Crown amended the initial assault charge to culpable homicide prior to Smith's guilty plea.
Violent Aftermath and Additional Assaults
Footage from Mr Harris-Richards' bodycam, presented in court, captured Smith yelling, "You're not allowed to touch me" and "Get your f---ing hands off me." She was heard taunting him, "Who do you think you are f---ing Hulk?" as she pulled at a bag containing bottles of alcohol she intended to sell to a pub.
After Mr Harris-Richards collapsed, Smith continued her violent behaviour, assaulting two female employees. She grabbed Chloe Robinson by the neck, threatening, "I will end you," and later punched her in the face and pulled her hair before fleeing the scene. Smith also pleaded guilty to assaulting Ms Robinson under protection of workers legislation.
Prosecutor Outlines Events Leading to Tragedy
Advocate depute Adrian Stalker explained that staff became suspicious of Smith in the spirits aisle. She proceeded to a self-service checkout with a can of alcohol and bags but then headed towards the exit, triggering alarms. Mr Harris-Richards and another staff member intercepted her, seizing a reusable bag with two bottles, but Smith refused to release it.
During the confrontation, Mr Harris-Richards' breathing became laboured, and he fell unconscious. Despite immediate first aid, CPR, and emergency medical treatment from staff, customers, and paramedics, he could not be revived. Mr Stalker emphasised the futile efforts to save him at the scene.
Defendant's Criminal History and Sentencing Adjournment
The court heard that Smith, a benefit claimant with one child in foster care, has an extensive criminal record for shoplifting, theft, drugs, and assault across Scotland and England, yet has never served a jail sentence before. Lord Haldane told Smith that the only appropriate outcome for her offending is "a significant custodial sentence."
Sentencing was adjourned for the preparation of a background report, with Smith remanded in custody. The judge underscored the severity of her actions, which led to the untimely death of a dedicated security guard.
