A question that has puzzled households for years has finally been answered by the professionals: should you put your bins out for collection if they aren't completely full? The debate, which often sparks discussion between neighbours, has been settled by binmen themselves, offering clarity on the most efficient and considerate approach.
The Reddit Question That Sparked a National Conversation
The topic gained significant traction on the online forum Reddit earlier this year, when a user directly asked binmen for their professional opinion. The user explained they often skipped putting bins out when they were only half-full, thinking they were saving the collection crew an unnecessary job. They wondered if this was appreciated or if it caused problems the following week when the bins might be overflowing.
The query prompted a flood of responses from current and former waste collection operatives, revealing a strong consensus. One binman wrote, "People complain if they put it out and it doesn't get emptied, no matter how little stuff is in it. If there is just a tied up bag in it, they just reach in, grab it and add it to a neighbours bin and tip that instead."
Another was unequivocal in their appreciation: "Yes, we appreciate it!! We can get through our round quicker, thank you! I can only speak for my crew, but we wish more people did this." This sentiment was echoed by others who explained that lifting multiple half-full bins is a significant "time drain" on their rounds.
Official Advice: It Depends on the Type of Waste
While the binmen's personal preference is clear, official guidance introduces an important nuance based on the type of waste involved. The general rule of thumb is that the advice differs for food waste versus dry recycling or general refuse.
For food or organic waste, it is almost always acceptable—and often recommended—to put out a partially filled bin. The reason is straightforward: leaving food waste to fester for an extra week can lead to unpleasant smells and attract pests like rats and flies. Most councils encourage regular collection of this waste stream regardless of volume.
However, for dry recycling (such as cardboard, plastic bottles, and tins) or general household waste that isn't perishable, the calculus changes. If these bins are less than half-full, many councils and the binmen themselves suggest it is perfectly fine to wait for the next scheduled collection. This practice helps to improve operational efficiency and conserve collection resources, as it means fewer stops for the lorries and less fuel consumption.
Why Skipping a Collection Can Be Helpful
The insights from the collection crews highlight several practical reasons for not automatically putting out a half-full bin. Firstly, it speeds up their rounds, allowing them to complete their routes more efficiently. Secondly, it can delay the point at which the collection vehicle becomes full, reducing the number of trips it needs to make to the depot to unload. This saves time and reduces emissions.
Furthermore, binmen pointed out a common frustration: residents who put out a nearly empty bin will often complain if it is missed, even though it contained very little. This can create unnecessary work for customer service teams at the local council.
The final word, however, always rests with your local authority. Council policies on waste collection can vary across different regions of the UK. Some may actively encourage residents to only present bins when full, while others may have strict rules requiring presentation every week. The best course of action is to check your specific council's website for definitive guidance.
In summary, the professionals have spoken: while you should always put out your food caddy, feel free to give your half-full recycling or general waste bin a week off. It's a small change that can make a big difference to the efficiency of a vital public service.
