Hibernian's quest for a defining victory this season was again postponed following a scrappy 1-1 draw away to Dundee United at Tannadice. The result, a seventh draw in 18 league matches, leaves significant questions hanging over the Easter Road side as they prepare for Saturday's pivotal Edinburgh derby against Hearts.
A Platform Lost? Hibs' Season of Stagnation
On paper, things are not disastrous for Hibernian. Under head coach David Gray, they sit fifth in the Scottish Premiership table, a position arguably in line with the club's budget. However, the palpable sense of momentum generated by last season's charge to third place has evaporated. The recent dissolution of the investment link with Bill Foley's Black Knight group in November has further fuelled a perception that the club's previously clear direction is now experiencing a wobble.
All is not lost, however. The teams above remain within reach, and a victory over city rivals Hearts this weekend would provide a massive injection of festive cheer and renewed vigour for the new year. But achieving that will require a level of performance far beyond what was shown in Tayside.
Tannadice Tale of Two Halves
The match itself followed a frustratingly familiar pattern for Hibs supporters. Dundee United's Luca Stephenson opened the scoring, only for Hibs captain Martin Boyle to equalise seven minutes before half-time. A header from debutant Zach Mitchell that struck the crossbar suggested a momentum swing in the visitors' favour after a first half where they enjoyed more possession and attempts.
The second half, however, was a profound disappointment. Hibs created very little, losing their composure and way as the game progressed. Substitute Thibault Klidje saw a chipped effort saved, and fellow sub Dylan Levitt skewed a late chance wide. In truth, their general play did not merit a winning goal, highlighting a chronic lack of clinical edge in key areas.
Individual Battles and World Cup Incentives
The spotlight falls on several individuals. Record signing Thibault Klidje, a £1 million arrival from Luzern, is at a critical juncture. With just five Premiership starts, two goals, and one assist, his return is underwhelming for a player of his fee and age. Forward Kieron Bowie, with three goals in his last 15 games, also needs to find consistency to bolster his World Cup squad hopes with Scotland.
Yet, there is no shortage of incentive within the squad. Boyle and Jack Iredale are likely headed to the World Cup with Australia. Grant Hanley is in prime position for Scotland, while Junior Hoilett (Canada), Rocky Bushiri (DR Congo), and Jamie McGrath (Republic of Ireland) all have international ambitions. This collective desire for global recognition should be the catalyst to finally grasp the thistle and spark their domestic season into life.
