Napoli have delivered a firm message regarding the future of Scott McTominay, effectively ending speculation about a sensational return to Manchester United for the in-form midfielder.
Manna's Clear Stance on McTominay's Napoli Role
Sporting director Giovanni Manna has made Napoli's position perfectly clear. When discussing the club's plans for the January 2026 transfer window, Manna emphasised McTominay's importance to the Serie A side. "We're waiting for [Frank] Anguissa, who is an important player, to come back," Manna stated. "We've missed him a lot. McTominay is showing that he can be decisive in that role. The coach will make his evaluations."
This public endorsement from the Napoli chief appears to shut down rumours that began circulating last month, which suggested a surprising comeback to Old Trafford could be on the cards for the 29-year-old Scotland international.
McTominay's Meteoric Rise in Italy
Since his £30million move from Manchester United to Naples in 2024, McTominay has transformed into one of Europe's most influential midfielders. His impact was immediate and profound.
He played a pivotal role in Napoli's title-winning campaign last season, scoring 12 goals in 34 games and earning the prestigious accolade of Serie A's Most Valuable Player. His rapid success in Italy has led many to label his sale as one of United's biggest transfer mistakes in recent memory.
Under manager Antonio Conte, McTominay has been a near-constant fixture in the team. While his goal tally this term hasn't matched last season's spectacular haul, he has still delivered in critical moments, netting important goals against the likes of Inter Milan in Serie A and PSV in the Champions League.
Why a Manchester United Return Looks Improbable
Despite the growing calls from some sections of the United fanbase for a reunion, a transfer in the near future seems highly unlikely for several key reasons.
Firstly, Napoli have no intention of selling their star midfielder. Reports suggest the Italian champions would only consider offers in the region of £60 million, a significant markup on the fee they paid just 18 months ago.
Secondly, such a move would contradict Manchester United's evolving transfer strategy under Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who has expressed a reluctance to invest heavily in older players. A £60m deal for a 29-year-old would starkly oppose this stated philosophy.
Furthermore, there is considerable uncertainty at Old Trafford following the departure of manager Ruben Amorim, leaving the club's recruitment priorities for the window unclear.
Perhaps most significantly, there is no guarantee McTominay himself would be open to a return. The midfielder is flourishing in Italy, enjoying a talismanic status and a defined role that he rarely experienced during his seven years in United's senior squad. He often found himself played out of position and never received the superstar treatment he now enjoys in Naples.
For United supporters, witnessing a former player reach his peak potential elsewhere may be a bitter pill to swallow. However, McTominay's story powerfully illustrates how a change of environment can unlock a player's true capabilities. All current evidence suggests his future remains firmly in Italy, where he has finally found the recognition and freedom to excel.
