Louis Tomlinson has launched a scathing critique of The X Factor, accusing the long-running ITV talent show of failing to provide adequate care for its contestants and describing it as 'unethical at times'. The singer, who rose to global fame after competing on the series in 2010 when he was placed into the boyband One Direction, expressed his gratitude for the opportunity but highlighted significant shortcomings in the programme's support systems.
Reflections on a Launchpad to Stardom
In a candid interview with The Sun, the 34-year-old artist acknowledged the transformative power of shows like The X Factor, which he credits for launching his singing career. 'I would never have been a singer if it wasn’t for that show. It is as simple as that,' Tomlinson stated. However, he emphasised that reflection reveals areas where the industry could improve its treatment of participants. 'I’m sure if we reflect on those shows, we could do better by the contestants,' he added, pointing to a need for enhanced duty of care protocols.
A Chorus of Criticism from Former Contestants
Tomlinson is not alone in his condemnation. A host of other former X Factor stars have come forward with similar grievances, painting a picture of a show that often leaves its contestants unsupported after their television journeys end.
- Christopher Maloney, who finished third in 2012, described a 'lack of support' post-show, linking it to his personal struggles with self-harm, body dysmorphia, and plastic surgery addiction. He told the Daily Mail that being 'catapulted into the spotlight' without guidance led to a breakdown, lamenting, 'you're left to your own devices. That's it.'
- Fleur East, the 2014 runner-up, felt 'put on a shelf' by Simon Cowell's company Syco after releasing just one album. She argued that participation should 'come with a warning' about the pitfalls of fame for young stars.
- Chico Slimane, a 2005 contestant, claimed the show 'uses and abuses you', prioritising profit over people. He asserted that artists are treated as 'a commodity' by producers who 'don't care about you'.
Allegations of Exploitation and Neglect
The criticisms extend beyond mere lack of support, with some alumni alleging active exploitation. Jedward launched a tirade against Simon Cowell, accusing him of acting like a 'mafia leader' in the music industry. Cher Lloyd, who competed at age 17 in 2010, said she was 'sold a dream' before being exploited, while Lloyd Daniels revealed he felt pressured to hide a same-sex relationship during his 2009 stint.
The tragic death of Liam Payne, Tomlinson's One Direction bandmate, in October 2024 has intensified scrutiny. Fellow 2010 contestant Katie Waissel accused music bosses of focusing on 'profits rather than people', stating in a tribute that 'the negligence of duty of care has once again led to a heart-wrenching loss'. Rebecca Ferguson, another 2010 participant, criticised the 'exploitation and profiteering of young stars', noting that many suffer lasting effects like PTSD.
The Legacy of a Television Phenomenon
The X Factor, which aired for 15 seasons from 2004 to 2018, became a cultural touchstone in the UK, launching the careers of acts like One Direction, Little Mix, Olly Murs, and Leona Lewis. Presented by figures such as Kate Thornton and Dermot O'Leary, and judged by celebrities including Sharon Osbourne and Cheryl, the show's format saw aspiring singers audition for a place in the live Saturday night broadcasts.
Despite its success stories, the mounting allegations suggest a darker side to the reality TV machine. As Tomlinson and others call for reform, the conversation shifts towards how the entertainment industry can better safeguard the wellbeing of its talent, balancing opportunity with ethical responsibility. The show's representatives at ITV and Syco have been contacted for comment, but the voices of former contestants continue to highlight a pressing need for change in how young artists are nurtured in the spotlight.
