The cinematic year of 2026 opens with a heartfelt, if somewhat syrupy, dose of musical nostalgia. Song Sung Blue, the new film from writer-director Craig Brewer, is a determined crowd-pleaser based on the remarkable true story of a Midwestern husband-and-wife Neil Diamond tribute act.
A True Story Brought to Life
Set in blue-collar Wisconsin in the mid-1990s, the film stars Hugh Jackman as Mike Sardina, a Vietnam War veteran and reformed troubadour who has been sober for two decades. Mike earns a living performing in bars as part of a troupe of singing impersonators, which includes a 'James Brown' (Mustafa Shakir) and, in a surprising piece of casting, a 'Buddy Holly' played by Michael Imperioli. Fans of The Sopranos may need a moment to adjust to seeing Imperioli, famed as mobster Christopher Moltisanti, crooning Holly's classics.
Mike's life changes when he meets Claire, a part-time hairdresser with a Patsy Cline act, portrayed by Kate Hudson. Their romance blossoms quickly, and they soon merge their talents to form the duo Lightning and Thunder, dedicated to performing Neil Diamond's extensive catalogue. The pair find modest success, even landing a coveted slot opening for the legendary rock band Pearl Jam.
Charm, Chemistry, and Catastrophe
The film's undeniable watchability for its first hour stems largely from the sparkling chemistry between its two leads. Jackman and Hudson not only act but perform all their own singing, delivering heartfelt renditions of Diamond's hits. Their domestic life, where Mike works to bond with Claire's two children from a previous relationship, is portrayed with warmth. The family dynamic is sweetened further by the heartwarming friendship that develops between their similarly-aged daughters, played by Ella Anderson and King Princess.
However, the narrative lacks significant conflict until a sudden and profound catastrophe strikes. This unexpected event, which we won't spoil here, shifts the film's tone dramatically. It replaces the story's curious, sustained buoyancy with a more conventional triumph-over-adversity dynamic, a staple of the cinematic crowd-pleaser.
Awards Buzz and Criticisms
Despite some narrative missteps, the performances are widely praised. Kate Hudson has already secured a Golden Globe nomination for her role, and it's easy to understand why when witnessing her whole-hearted commitment. Jackman is equally compelling as the gentle, steadfast Mike.
Yet, the film is not without its flaws. At two hours and 13 minutes, it feels stretched, and a cheesiness pervades the enterprise that can border on the sickly for more discerning viewers. One particular scene involving a teenage mother giving up her newborn is criticised for its glib treatment of a sensitive subject. Additionally, some slapstick feels misjudged, and a supporting turn by Jim Belushi is singled out for its over-the-top delivery.
Inspired by a 2008 documentary of the same name, Song Sung Blue is a film of contrasts. It might be the perfect, undemanding holiday hangover cure for some, while for others its sentimental flavour could induce a headache. Ultimately, it serves as a pleasant, music-filled start to the year, powered by the considerable charm of its stellar leads. Song Sung Blue is in cinemas now.
