Renowned television creator Ryan Murphy is encountering significant criticism for his latest project, a dramatised portrayal of the relationship between John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette. The official trailer for FX's Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette was released on Monday, featuring Paul Kelly and Sarah Pidgeon in the lead roles. The limited series is scheduled to premiere on February 12, 2026.
Family Outrage and Public Disapproval
The forthcoming series has drawn immediate ire, particularly from the Kennedy family. JFK Jr.'s nephew, Jack Schlossberg, issued a public statement condemning the production. He confirmed that the family was not consulted about the project and expressed dismay that Murphy appeared to be "profiting off of it in a grotesque way." Murphy's response to these concerns, suggesting Schlossberg's objections were odd given he "really don't remember" his uncle, further inflamed the situation.
Social Media and Viewer Backlash
Online reaction to the trailer and Murphy's comments has been overwhelmingly negative. Commenters on platforms like YouTube and Reddit have labelled the project as exploitative and unnecessary. One viewer remarked it was "something no one asked for" and urged that the couple be allowed to rest in peace. Others criticised the perceived lack of historical accuracy and the "cheap soapy garbage" treatment of sensitive subject matter.
A Pattern of Controversial Portrayals
This is not the first time Ryan Murphy has faced accusations of exploiting tragedy for entertainment. His previous works, including the series about serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer and Monster: The Erik and Lyle Menendez Story, have been similarly criticised for glamorising violent criminals and profiting from real-life suffering. Critics argue this new series continues a troubling pattern of disrespecting victims and their families under the guise of dramatic storytelling.
Casting and Creative Choices Scrutinised
Initial pushback began last summer when first-look images of Pidgeon and Kelly in character were released. Audiences questioned the casting decisions and costume designs, arguing they failed to respectfully capture the essence of the famously private couple. JFK Jr. and Bessette, who died in a plane crash in 1999, were known for their intense desire for privacy from the media spotlight—a fact that makes this very public dramatisation particularly contentious for many.
The controversy highlights ongoing debates in the entertainment industry about the ethics of biographical storytelling, especially concerning recent tragedies and living relatives. As the premiere date approaches, the backlash against Murphy's latest venture shows no signs of abating, with many calling for more sensitive handling of such personal histories.
