The chief constable of West Midlands Police has retired with immediate effect following a damning report into his handling of a controversial ban on Israeli football supporters.
Chief Constable Steps Down After Losing Confidence
Chief Constable Craig Guildford announced his sudden departure on Friday 16 January 2026. This came after Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood publicly stated he "no longer has my confidence" following the release of a critical report. Ms Mahmood said his decision to retire was "the right thing to do".
Report Uncovers 'Catalogue of Failings'
The investigation centred on Mr Guildford's actions regarding the ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans from a Europa League match. The report found he had exaggerated evidence and included inaccuracies to justify the decision. Among the serious errors highlighted was the inclusion of an 'AI hallucination'—fabricated information generated by artificial intelligence—within the evidence presented.
Home Secretary Mahmood stated the report revealed a "catalogue of failings" that had significantly damaged public trust in the force.
Leadership Change and Future of the Force
The West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner, Simon Foster, welcomed Mr Guildford's retirement. He has appointed Deputy Chief Constable Scott Green to serve as the acting chief constable while a permanent replacement is sought.
This episode marks a significant crisis for one of the UK's largest police forces, raising serious questions about decision-making processes and the use of intelligence at the highest levels of command.
