Scotland's Children's Commissioner has warned that a ban on social media for under-16s could drive young people to "darker places on the internet." Nicola Killean expressed disappointment with the UK Government's stance, arguing that the current evidence does not support a blanket ban as an effective way to protect children online.
Concerns Over the Ban
Speaking out after Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer announced plans to restrict social media access for under-16s, Killean said the move could have unintended consequences. Starmer stated the government is "giving children their childhoods back" amid concerns over mental health and safety risks. However, Killean argued that children may be less likely to report harmful content if they fear repercussions.
A children's rights impact assessment by her office found that a ban would not be "proportionate, effective, or enforceable." She noted that evidence from Australia shows most children still access social media despite bans. "There is a real risk now that children will be driven to darker places on the internet and stop talking to adults about what they might see," she said.
Mixed Reactions
The NSPCC welcomed the measures as a win for child protection, but Killean emphasized the need for stronger platform regulation rather than punishing children. She called on the UK Government to address children directly and ensure they can report harmful content without blame. Minister for Children and Young People Siobhian Brown supported the ban but demanded clearer plans for holding social media companies accountable, including a potential Social Media Levy.
The ban is expected to be passed by Christmas and implemented by spring, placing liability on tech firms. However, Killean warned that vulnerable groups, such as disabled children and those in rural areas, would be disproportionately affected.
