More than two decades after the first film's release, a long-running debate among Harry Potter fans appears to have reached a definitive conclusion. The question: can the beloved wizarding saga truly be classified as a collection of Christmas films?
The Great Festive Debate Settled
It has been over 24 years since Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone first hit cinemas, yet the discussion about its festive credentials has persisted. While the films are television staples throughout December, fans have only recently cemented their collective verdict on whether they belong in the Christmas movie canon.
The tradition of having the TV on in the background during the holidays, filled with festive specials and classic films, often sparks disagreement. The core argument typically hinges on whether a movie needs to be set during the Christmas period to earn the label. For many, the Harry Potter series, particularly the first film, with its iconic snowy Hogwarts scenes, has always felt intrinsically linked to the season.
The Official Word from the Wizarding World
As fans deliberated, the official Harry Potter TikTok account stepped in to present a compelling case. They outlined three definitive reasons why Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone is, without doubt, a Christmas film.
Firstly, they pointed to the "gorgeous" snowy scenery and decorations. The account highlighted the memorable moment of "Hagrid dragging the huge tree" into the Great Hall, a scene that epitomises festive transformation and wonder.
The second reason centred on the film's magical and atmospheric soundtrack. The account noted that "whether it's the tinkly bell sounds or the swelling crescendos, there's something that reminds us of Christmas," weaving a sonic tapestry that feels inherently seasonal.
A Heart-Warming Holiday First
Perhaps the most poignant argument focused on narrative. The TikTok stated the film showcases Harry's first proper Christmas, away from the neglectful Dursleys. "Harry waking up to a Christmas gift on Christmas Day is one of the most heart-warming scenes of the whole film," they argued, anchoring the story in a core festive theme of family, belonging, and joy.
Fans Embrace the Festive Verdict
The response from the fan community was overwhelmingly in agreement. In the comments, one dedicated Potterhead declared, "Potterheads know all too well that the magic of Christmas is intertwined with Harry's story. Don't deny it, these films are perfect for the holiday season."
Others simply expressed their affection for the Christmas atmosphere within the films, with one writing "Love The Christmas in Harry Potter very much." Another fan went so far as to compare it to a contentious festive favourite, boldly stating: "More Christmas than Die Hard. I said it."
Ultimately, beyond the official arguments, the films have earned their place on festive watchlists due to a powerful blend of magical themes and pure nostalgia. For a generation that grew up with the Boy Who Lived, returning to Hogwarts each December feels as traditional as mince pies and fairy lights, proving that the spirit of Christmas can indeed be found in the most magical of places.
