Australia's Fashion Brain Drain: Why Designers Leave and Rarely Return

Australia's Fashion Brain Drain: Why Designers Leave and Rarely Return

Australia's fashion industry faces a significant challenge: while it produces world-class design talent, it struggles to retain them. Analysis of the Australian Fashion Foundation scholarship winners reveals a stark pattern of emigration, with only three of nineteen recipients between 2009 and 2019 returning to design roles within Australian fashion businesses.

The International Dream Versus Local Reality

Vlad Kanevsky, now a senior designer at Thom Browne in New York, exemplifies this trend. While studying fashion at RMIT in Melbourne, international runway shows seemed like "a fever dream" to him. After a decade in the industry abroad, he notes that "things that didn't seem possible in Australia have become a reality."

Kanevsky articulates a common sentiment among expatriate Australian designers: "I love Australia, but being so geographically far away and isolated, there aren't that many career options, which is why I haven't considered returning yet."

—

Historical Context and Modern Challenges

Australia's fashion industry has always maintained an outward focus. When David Jones opened in the 19th century, it imported Parisian garments, establishing early international connections. The mid-20th century saw a flourishing local design community supported by skilled manufacturers benefiting from import tariffs.

This period produced internationally successful brands including Collette Dinnigan, Akira Isogawa, Zimmermann, and Sass & Bide. However, the early 2000s brought political, digital, and market changes that caused the local industry to struggle, prompting millennial graduates to seek opportunities in global fashion capitals.

The Scholarship Pathway Abroad

In 2009, Australian expatriates Malcolm Carfrae and Julie Anne Quay established the Australian Fashion Foundation scholarship, offering $20,000 and an internship at a luxury fashion house. Initially focused on New York, the program expanded to Europe over time.

Carfrae explains the foundation's philosophy: "to help young Australians gain world-class, hands-on international experience. It serves to further expand and enrich the future of Australian fashion."

Of the nineteen winners in the scholarship's first decade, Guardian Australia analysis found that nine continue working in New York, Paris, London, or Milan. Only three have returned to Australian design roles, with just one launching her own label locally.

The Scale Problem

Carfrae attributes the low return rate to "scarcity" of design positions in Australia. The Australian Fashion Council estimates 364,000 people work in the country's $27.2 billion fashion industry, but Jobs and Skills Australia data suggests only about 3,700 (approximately 1%) are designers.

Carfrae emphasizes that international training remains "important" regardless of whether recipients return. The scholarship paused in 2025 but will resume in 2026.

Career Trajectories Overseas

Georgia Lazzaro, the first scholarship winner, completed internships at Narciso Rodriguez and Calvin Klein in New York. She spent fifteen years there before returning to a design role at Matteau in Sydney this year.

Talisa Trantino, the 2013 winner, built an impressive resume including positions at Alexander McQueen, Celine, Bottega Veneta, Wales Bonner, and most recently as head of jewellery and special projects at Loewe. Despite wanting to be closer to family, she finds returning difficult.

"It's such a conflict of mine because I love Australia but leaving now feels like turning your back on something you've worked so hard to build," Trantino says. "I don't know if there is an opportunity that could excite me enough to bring me home."

Manufacturing Limitations

A key concern for designers considering return is Australia's diminished manufacturing capacity. Only 3% of garments sold in Australia are made domestically, limiting opportunities to work with skilled artisans.

Trantino questions whether Australia can compare with European luxury houses in "really fine-tuning craft into products." In response, the Australian Fashion Council launched a ten-year manufacturing strategy on 12 March aimed at rebuilding the sector.

Creativity Within Constraints

Some designers find that creativity thrives under limitations. Natalia Grzybowski, who won a scholarship in 2011, built her career in Australia, currently serving as creative director at swim and resort brand Bondi Born.

While acknowledging the appeal of working abroad with "endless options" for intricate embroideries and beautiful materials, Grzybowski argues that "working within constraints requires a different type of creativity."

"There is opportunity here. I partly stayed because I wanted to create that for other people," she explains. "If everyone leaves, you don't have anyone here. We can have a fantastic industry, so I'm always going to encourage people to stay."

Returning Challenges

Designers returning after international careers face specific obstacles. Set designer Athanasia Spathis worked almost ten years in London and Paris for clients including Louis Vuitton, Dior, and Vogue before returning early in the pandemic.

She describes her Australian work as "diluted both financially and creatively," noting that European projects offer bigger budgets and more collaborative freedom with references drawn from diverse sources like cinema and arts.

Optimism and Adaptation

Despite challenges, some returnees express optimism. Lazzaro, who returned primarily for family reasons, finds the local industry has "a sense of pride" and describes returning as "really exciting."

Jewellery designer Seb Brown, who founded his business in Melbourne in 2009, recalls "glory days of retail" with incubator stores that helped launch brands. However, he eventually felt "a ceiling" in the local market.

In June 2024, Brown opened a Paris arm of his business while maintaining his Melbourne atelier. He finds Paris offers better proximity to global buyers and media, but describes business operations there as "fairly backwards" compared to Australia's "get up and go, let's give it a crack attitude."

Brown acknowledges the tension many Australian designers face: "I felt I had to explore outside of Australia to grow and be taken a little more seriously. I guess I'll always have to be travelling back and forth."

The Australian fashion industry thus navigates a complex reality: producing exceptional talent while competing with global centers that offer greater scale, manufacturing capabilities, and career opportunities. The brain drain continues, but voices like Grzybowski's maintain hope for a revitalized domestic industry that can eventually retain more of its homegrown designers.