A statement explaining why Jonathan Tah's goal for Germany was disallowed against Paraguay has been issued, following a controversial VAR decision that saw Germany crash out of the World Cup 2026 in the round of 32.
The Disallowed Goal
In the first half of extra time, with the score level at 0-0, Bayern Munich defender Tah appeared to put Germany ahead for the first time in the tie. However, after Tah celebrated with teammates, the game was delayed as Paraguay players appealed that goalkeeper Orlando Gill had been fouled. Referee Jalal Jayed was advised by the Video Assistant Referee to review the incident on the pitch-side monitor.
Following the review, Jayed issued a statement to the crowd explaining that the goal was disallowed because Germany substitute Waldemar Anton had committed a foul on Gill. Former England captain Alan Shearer, commentating for the BBC, called the decision "very, very soft." Shearer said, "Not for me, I don't agree with that decision at all. I don't agree with that. The 'keeper buys it [the contact]. Very, very soft, that is, very soft."
Turning Point and Penalty Shootout
The decision proved to be the turning point in Boston, as neither side could force a winner before the end of extra time, leading to the first penalty shootout of World Cup 2026. In a huge shock, Paraguay emerged victorious after Kai Havertz, Nick Woltemade, and Tah all failed to convert from 12 yards. Paraguay themselves had two opportunities to win the shootout before central defender Jose Canale converted the decisive spot-kick.
Aftermath
Paraguay will progress to the last-16, where they will face the winner of the France and Sweden tie. Germany, meanwhile, are left to reflect on a controversial decision as their wait to reach a World Cup round of 16 will stretch into a 16th year.
