Independent MP Helen Haines, a key architect of the National Anti-Corruption Commission (Nacc), has called for a transparent and merit-based process to replace deputy commissioner Nicole Rose, who announced her resignation this month. Haines, who sits on the parliamentary oversight committee, emphasized that the appointment is a critical opportunity to restore public confidence in the watchdog.
Urgency of the Appointment
Haines stated that “the clock is ticking” on replacing Rose, who is relocating overseas and will leave her role later this month after a period of leave. She stressed that a clear and transparent process would assist the joint committee in fulfilling its duty to review and approve appointments.
Strengthening Public Confidence
“Recruitment for a new deputy commissioner is a critical opportunity for the government to strengthen public confidence in the National Anti-Corruption Commission,” Haines told Guardian Australia. She has rarely commented on Nacc operations due to her oversight responsibilities.
Background and Controversies
The call comes amid a controversial first five years for the Nacc, including criticism over commissioner Paul Brereton’s external work for Defence and the handling of referrals related to the illegal robodebt scheme. The Nacc’s initial decision not to investigate robodebt was heavily criticized, with over 1,000 complaints received.
A report by Nacc inspector Gail Furness in October 2024 found that Brereton was “affected by apprehended bias” and should have recused himself from related decisions. The Nacc noted the report contained “no finding of intentional wrongdoing or other impropriety.” Brereton had also performed consulting work for the inspector general of the Australian defence force while serving as commissioner.
Call for Reform
Haines argued that Labor must appoint a new commissioner through “a transparent, merit-based process that Australians can have confidence in.” She added, “Australians should understand what skills and experience are required for the role, as well as how candidates will be assessed and conflicts of interest declared.”
In the longer term, Haines suggested considering legislation for an independent, merit-based process for all senior Nacc appointments. “The clock is ticking, with Ms Rose taking leave from late May and no acting appointment announced. It’s important there is sufficient time for a thorough and considered selection process,” she said.
Current Nacc Operations
The Nacc’s most recent public update revealed it is conducting 29 preliminary investigations and 36 corruption investigations. Four matters are currently before the courts, and 11 convictions have been secured as a result of its investigations.
