Is Travel to the USA Now an Ethical Dilemma Amid Political Turmoil?
As a travel writer, I am often asked about the ethics and practicality of visiting various international destinations. I never anticipated that the United States would become a country that travellers are actively avoiding. Yet, over the past year, the Trump administration has transformed the US into a place perceived as unwelcoming, unsettling, and potentially dangerous. A recent survey by Simon Calder for The Independent revealed that 80% of respondents plan to avoid travelling to the US, with only 11% still willing to go. Among those with booked holidays, one in seven are considering cancellations. Many have already decided it is not acceptable to visit the US at this time, while others seek guidance from experts like myself.
Personal and Professional Perspectives on Visiting
From a personal standpoint, I will continue to visit the US because my sister and her family reside in California, making it impossible for me to abandon the country entirely. I know numerous wonderful individuals in the travel, hospitality, and arts industries who vehemently oppose the current regime and strive to make others feel welcome and secure. As a journalist, turning away from these voices feels wrong, especially when I have the platform to amplify resistance. Having grown up in Belfast during the 1980s and 1990s, when tourism was scarce, I understand the impact of isolation. I believe that responsible travel can be a force for good, uncovering positive stories in every location. Thus, for both personal and professional reasons, I remain committed to visiting.
Growing Calls for Boycotts and Safety Concerns
However, I fully support travellers who refuse to go. There are increasing calls for an international boycott of the US due to alleged violations of international law, including a proposed boycott of the upcoming FIFA World Cup, which the US is co-hosting with Mexico and Canada. French MP Eric Coquerel of the left-wing La France Insoumise party questioned the feasibility of holding the event in a country that attacks neighbours and disregards global norms. High-profile figures, from musicians to social media influencers, are also refusing to travel in solidarity with those from nations on the Trump administration's travel ban list. History shows that sanctions and boycotts can penalise authoritarian regimes, and many travellers are resolved not to spend money in the US during this presidency.
Safety is another major concern. As a white Irish citizen, my experience is privileged compared to Black and minority ethnic friends who have long been wary of American law enforcement and are now more fearful than ever. Incidents like the shooting of civilian protesters by ICE agents in Minneapolis highlight the risks. During anti-ICE protests in New York City last March, I felt safe, but I did not foresee that over 40 people would later be killed by federal agents or die in custody. The reality is that the situation may worsen, adding to travellers' anxieties.
Immigration Hurdles and Economic Impact
Travellers also worry about navigating US immigration. The proposed Electronic System for Travel Authorisation (Esta) requirements demand extensive personal data, including social media identifiers, phone numbers, email addresses, and IP addresses from the past five to ten years. This is not only invasive but also a significant hassle. The World Travel and Tourism Council predicts these changes could reduce international arrivals by 4.7 million in 2026, cutting visitor spending by up to $15.7 billion and causing wider GDP losses of $21.5 billion. As a journalist on an I-Visa, I have written critically of the government, raising concerns about what travellers might face at immigration.
Additionally, travel insurance and tour operator policies add complexity. Sean Tipton of Abta notes that standard travel insurance does not cover trips against Foreign Office advice, which many see as too risky given the current climate.
Tourism Challenges and Responsible Travel
This year was supposed to be prosperous for US tourism, marking the 250th anniversary of American independence and the 100th anniversary of Route 66, with new museums like the Obama Presidential Centre opening. The World Cup was expected to attract millions of visitors. I do not judge those who proceed with plans to visit destinations like New Orleans for Mardi Gras or Utah's national parks. The US remains a vast country with much to offer, despite political tensions. As the third most-visited nation globally, a tourism slump would devastate local communities. Travellers can act responsibly by supporting ethical local businesses and groups.
In conclusion, there are valid reasons both to visit and to avoid the US. The decision is more complex than ever, and we must acknowledge that normality is not an option in these turbulent times.
