A professional dog trainer and behaviourist has revealed the three dog breeds he deeply admires but would never personally own, emphasising that this decision stems from lifestyle incompatibility rather than any fault with the animals themselves.
The Expert's Perspective on Breed Selection
Will Atherton, an experienced dog trainer, stresses that choosing a canine companion should be a rational decision based on practical considerations rather than emotional appeal. He explains that factors such as temperament, exercise requirements, and living environment must align with an owner's daily life. For instance, a Border Collie demands extensive daily walking, making it unsuitable for someone unable to commit to such activity.
"Choosing a breed isn’t about what looks coolest. It’s about what fits your lifestyle. The right dog for you is way better than your 'dream breed'," Atherton advises, urging prospective owners to "think with your head and not with your heart".
The Three Breeds: Admired Yet Unsuited
Kangal Shepherd Dog
Will Atherton describes the Kangal Shepherd Dog as one of his "favourite breeds in the world", praising its "stoic intensity", "incredible presence", and calm, powerful nature. Bred historically for guarding livestock independently, these dogs possess remarkable qualities.
However, Atherton highlights that their specific needs make ownership impractical for him. "They need space, purpose, and a very specific lifestyle, and realistically, that’s not my day-to-day life," he explains, adding that acquiring one would be for "purely ego" reasons rather than genuine suitability.
Cane Corso
Another breed in Atherton's top three is the Cane Corso, which he "absolutely loves" and considers "the best of the mastiff breeds". He previously owned one that tragically died young from a hereditary heart condition.
Despite his affection, Atherton notes he tends to "never have the same dog breed twice" to avoid feeling like he is replacing a past pet. He also points out that Cane Corsos present "difficulties and challenges" that other breeds, such as German Shepherds, do not, making them less suitable for his current circumstances.
Jack Russell Terrier
Growing up with Jack Russell Terriers, Atherton holds them "incredibly close" to his heart, cherishing memories of their tenacious, cheeky, and feisty characteristics. He "loves and adores" their spirited nature.
Nevertheless, he admits "they're just really hard work" and do not align with his present "day-to-day" life. Atherton cautions that potential owners must be prepared to handle their assertive personality, noting that breeds like Labradors, Golden Retrievers, and German Shepherds better suit his lifestyle as they can be trained "to much higher standards".
Conclusion: Prioritising Practicality Over Preference
Will Atherton's insights underscore a crucial message for prospective dog owners: breed selection should prioritise practical compatibility over personal preference. By sharing his experiences with these three admired breeds, he illustrates how even beloved dogs may not fit into one's lifestyle, reinforcing the importance of responsible pet ownership based on realistic assessment rather than idealised dreams.
